Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Student Device Policy topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Board adopts instructional-time phone policy, urges further study of bell-to-bell ban
Summary
The Roseville Joint Union High School District board approved a mobile-device policy that limits phone use during instructional time but stopped short of adopting a full "bell-to-bell" phone ban, directing staff to study the stricter option and solicit broader stakeholder input.
The Roseville Joint Union High School District Board of Trustees voted to adopt revised policy 5131.8, limiting student mobile device use during instructional time while asking staff to evaluate the feasibility of a stricter bell-to-bell ban.
Trustee Tiffany (Trustee Shoots) opened the discussion with data and examples from nearby districts that have adopted bell-to-bell rules, saying the tighter restriction "provides students with an average of 7 hours each school day to be fully present and free from the pressures and harms of phones and social media." She asked the board to delay final adoption in order to seek broader stakeholder input and study potential mental-health benefits.
Several trustees and district staff pressed back on practical and safety concerns. One trustee said emergency reporting tools and the district's existing threat-assessment procedures rely on phones, and noted that many students are 17 or 18 and use phones for legitimate scheduling and family communications. A staff member explained that the policy before the board creates an instructional-time limitation and that several schools have already piloted related approaches.
After extended debate over teacher discretion, campus logistics (caddies, theft, supervision), and equity of enforcement across sites, the board approved the instructional-time policy as presented. Trustees also asked staff to monitor or report back on implementation and to research the potential impacts and feasibility of a bell-to-bell rule, including family and site council input.
The vote to adopt policy 5131.8 was recorded as passing without opposition. The board chair said the district will implement classroom-level expectations and provide a check-in after initial implementation to assess whether further action is warranted.
Staff noted existing exceptions: emergency access, medical accommodations (IEP/504) and teacher-directed instructional uses remain allowed under the adopted language. The board directed student services to collect implementation feedback from site councils and report back to the board within roughly a year, with an interim check-in planned earlier.
