Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Criminal Law topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Some delegates oppose third‑degree assault bill over District Court commissioner limitation; bill still passes
Summary
Senate Bill 514 on third-degree assault was amended and passed by the committee, but several members, including Delegate Valentine, said they would vote no because the Senate language limits a District Court commissioner’s authority and is an uncommon restriction in Maryland law.
Senate Bill 514, which revises third-degree assault provisions, was considered with amendments and passed out of committee by a 13–5 roll call. The amendment clarified technical and drafting points and retained language from the Senate version regarding a District Court commissioner’s authority.
During debate, some members said they supported the underlying policy but opposed the commissioner-language provision. Delegate Valentine said she would "vote no on this bill simply because of the provision for the District Court Commissioner provision that was in this in the Senate version," explaining that she could not think of another Maryland statute that limits a commissioner's authority in this way and that the provision could have consequences given incarceration as a penalty.
Committee members discussed how the provision functions (a "must appear" requirement remains; failure to appear can prompt a bench warrant or body attachment) and ultimately adopted the amendment. After roll call the motion carried 13–5. The committee recorded members asking for the provision to be reconsidered in future drafting or on the floor.
The committee reported the bill favorably, but members opposing the specific commissioner language put their objections on the record for subsequent consideration.
