Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Immigration Enforcement Policy topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Somerville council debates local limits on municipal cooperation with federal immigration enforcement
Summary
After a resident request, Somerville council discussed a draft resolution that would restrict borough employees, assets and facilities from aiding federal immigration enforcement when officers are not clearly identified; borough attorney warned of limits on controlling federal behavior and members said they will monitor state actions.
Somerville borough council on Feb. 2 debated whether to craft local policy limiting municipal personnel and resources from assisting federal immigration enforcement actions when federal officers do not clearly identify themselves.
The item arose after a resident letter asking the borough to adopt language that would bar borough employees and resources from supporting federal immigration enforcement activities conducted by officers who conceal their identities. The proposed resolution would limit assistance unless federal officers clearly display identifying information and would prohibit use of borough funds, equipment or facilities when federal officers are masked or otherwise unidentifiable.
Council members cited the New Jersey Trust Directive and related state guidance. The borough attorney advised that municipalities cannot directly control federal agents' conduct but can condition local cooperation. "You can condition our municipal officers' cooperation with the police with federal agents," the attorney said, noting the borough could refuse to cooperate if federal agents remained masked or failed to present judicial warrants.
Several council members said they prefer to watch for state-level action and to avoid overstepping municipal authority, while others and several public commenters urged local action now. A resident who identified herself as Mallalerie argued the borough should not wait for the state to act and invoked the anti-commandeering doctrine in support of local safeguards for municipal resources. "The federal government should not be imposing itself in our municipal local government," she said during public comment.
Council members also emphasized the need to preserve trust between residents and the Somerville Police Department. Some council members said they would like language that makes clear the police's primary role is protecting residents and that municipal officers should not be positioned to shield federal officers from public scrutiny during enforcement operations.
The council did not adopt new local restrictions at the meeting. Members said they will monitor developments at the state level, including any action by Governor Murphy's successor and state directives, and consult the borough attorney on options that would be legally permissible and practical for local implementation.
