Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Public Works topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Town public-works officials tell school committee town cannot absorb full snow-removal duties without more staff or budget
Summary
Smithfield public-works officials told the school committee the town prioritizes roads and lacks the staff and budget to take over all school snow removal; DPW cited a $236,000 salt bill in a recent year and said adding school routes would effectively require another full plow route.
Smithfield public-works officials told the school committee on Nov. 14 that the town cannot absorb the district’s full snow-removal responsibility without additional personnel, vehicles or funding.
Jean Allen, the town’s director of public works, said the DPW’s first priority is clearing roads and that its winter operation is “very lean,” with roughly 17 primary routes and 19 drivers. “Anything that’s asked of us, we will do. Okay? We’re here to help and try to help with all the facilities within the town where we can,” Allen said, but she warned adding the schools’ 63,000 square yards of pavement — about 4.91 miles — would amount to assigning “another whole route to the town.”
Allen provided concrete budget context: the town spent about $236,000 on salt in one recent year and roughly $206,000 in a prior season, while the DPW’s road-materials line was budgeted at $200,000 after an earlier increase. Committee members noted the school’s contracted snow budget has varied widely (committee materials show years with school spending above $34,000 and other years near $10,000), and they asked whether the town’s procurement networks or consolidated contracts could lower costs.
DPW staff and committee members described the current mix of approaches: the school department bids a three-year incremental contract with private contractors that handle large-lot clearing and use wide loaders, while the town supplies salt and sand from its shed and will divert staff to help when needed. Officials said outside contractor trucks with sanding and plow equipment can exceed $200 per hour for a single truck, and that long storms (dozens of hours) multiply hourly costs quickly.
Town staff emphasized operational trade-offs: routing the town to handle school lots during storms would increase route lengths, raise the risk of school delays or cancellations if roads must be cleared first, and require hiring more drivers or paying higher contractor rates for private trucks. The DPW also noted fleet-age and reliability concerns — several large trucks are more than 25 years old and one truck was retired earlier in the year — which constrain redundancy during multi-day storms.
Committee members proposed several near-term steps: (1) examine whether the school and town can share forecasting services or a single meteorological provider to reduce duplicate subscriptions; (2) review the snow-contract bid structure (town managers noted some contract prices have remained flat); and (3) include clearer line-item reporting for salt and contractor hours when the committee next considers vehicle or capital requests for school operations.
The committee and town officials did not adopt any formal change to contracts or staffing at the meeting; they agreed to continue the discussion, exchange budget documentation, and revisit the topic in upcoming joint sessions.
Next steps: town DPW staff will provide additional operational cost details and the school committee will consider whether to re-run the snow-contract RFP with consolidated forecasting or procurement assumptions.
