Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Small Business Land Use topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Planning commissioners endorse ice-kiosk rule in community-commercial zones with special-use review
Summary
After an applicant described a Twice-the-Ice vending machine and site plan for a family property on Saginaw Boulevard, the commission recommended adding an "ice kiosk" use to the ordinance and restricting it to community-commercial zoning by specific-use permit to preserve oversight of site layout and circulation.
The Saginaw Planning & Zoning Commission voted to recommend adding a new defined use, "ice kiosk," to the city's permitted-use table and to allow the use in the community-commercial zoning district subject to a specific-use permit.
Jennifer and Scott Craver appeared as applicants for an ice-and-water vending kiosk on family-owned property at 345 N. Saginaw Boulevard. The applicants said the Twice the Ice machine is self-service, operates 24 hours, requires minimal staffing, and uses two or more on-site parking spaces for short-dwell trades; the family noted it has owned the property since 1958 and intends to maintain long-term ownership.
'This is a self-service, low-impact use,' Scott Craver said, adding staff won't be required and the machine would sit on a cement platform with protective bollards and on-site parking.
Staff told commissioners that two similar machines have operated in Saginaw in the past; previous approvals were administratively classified as retail but the staff determined ice kiosks do not fall cleanly under existing categories and recommended adding a definition plus a review pathway. Commissioners and staff discussed circulation, parking on private property, sanitation/health compliance and consistency with the Saginaw Boulevard overlay.
A commissioner moved to add the defined use (staff's suggested language: a self-service machine or booth where people buy ice, typically located outside stores, gas stations or parking lots), allow it in the community-commercial district, and require a specific-use permit so the city can review siting and conditions. The motion passed.
What happens next: if council adopts the commission's recommendation the Cravers or other businesses would file SUP applications and then building, health, and fire permits as required; staff emphasized that permitting by right would not bypass building- or health-related approvals.
Why it matters: commissioners described the kiosk as a low-impact consumer service but said the SUP requirement will give the city discretion to address circulation, parking and aesthetics in the Boulevard overlay. Applicants cited a third-party market report projecting about 26,000 annual vends for a kiosk in a comparable location.
