Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Public Safety topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Firefighters urge council for respectful, data‑driven debate, cite morale and recruitment concerns
Summary
During open forum at Dayton City Council, firefighters said recent council remarks have damaged morale, hurting recruitment and retention, and urged more professional, fact‑based discussions; council members responded with apologies and clarifications about oversight and budgeting.
Brad Brigamin, speaking at the Dayton City Council open forum on Nov. 25, read a letter signed by a majority of the city’s firefighters accusing some recent council remarks of undermining department morale, retention and recruitment. “The current negativity towards the department, its leadership, and our handling of public safety hurts firefighter morale and public perception,” Brigamin said, asking that future council discussions be “conducted in a professional and respectful manner.”
Another firefighter and resident, Ralph Ash, told the council he fears the tones taken in public debate could discourage recruits and worsen staffing challenges. “This past year suggests that they are more willing to compromise and sacrifice the safety and service of this community for the sake of personal pride and vendettas,” Ash said, urging reconciliation and restoration of trust with department leadership.
Council members responded during general comments. Councilor Scott apologized for an earlier remark and several members discussed whether posting the firefighters’ letter online before council receipt was appropriate; some councilors framed their scrutiny as fiscal oversight rather than retaliation. Councilors also emphasized the city’s fiscal constraints and the need to weigh equipment and staffing proposals against a long list of projected capital needs.
Mayor and staff thanked the firefighters for their service and said the administration will continue to address operational questions through data and formal staff reports. Chief-level staff and city administrators reiterated a desire to work collaboratively with the council to balance public safety needs and budget constraints.
The public comments followed a packed agenda that included updates on infrastructure projects, a lengthy presentation from Three Rivers Park District about a regional trail, and votes on firefighter pay and equipment. No council action was taken directly from the open forum remarks; the speakers’ concerns were referred to staff for follow up as is city policy.
