Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the National Guard topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Commissioner says local National Guard unit didn’t receive plaque; mayor, staff point to miscommunication
Summary
At an April 20 Carter County commission meeting Commissioner James Byrd said local National Guard members told him they never received a plaque or proclamation; the commission read a letter from the Tennessee Military Department thanking Mayor Patty Woodby for outreach but residents pressed for clarity on whether the local unit was recognized.
Commissioner James Byrd told the Carter County Board of Commissioners on April 20 that local National Guard members told him they did not receive a plaque or proclamation the county said it presented after Hurricane Helene relief efforts. "If you want to say I'm lying, take a trip up to the National Guard, walk in the door, talk to them," Byrd said, adding that he had discussed the issue with Tennessee Military Department leadership and had a copy of their letter.
Byrd said the discrepancy prompted accusations from other commissioners and urged colleagues to verify accounts with the local unit instead of questioning his motives. The item came during the public-comment portion of a meeting that also included routine appointments and budget votes.
A commission committee chair acknowledged a miscommunication about how plaques were delivered and "took full responsibility" for the mix-up, saying the committee that arranged the recognition should have informed the full membership. Several residents backed Byrd's account at the meeting; Lawrence Street, a District 1 resident, said local guard members told him they received no plaque and criticized what he described as insufficient mayoral attention to local responders.
The commission also read into the record a letter from the Tennessee Military Department acknowledging the county's resolution and thanking Mayor Patty Woodby for leading a delegation of East Tennessee mayors to a National Guard Association event in 2025. The letter — written by senior military leadership and supplied to commissioners — praised the mayor's outreach to soldiers and airmen but did not resolve residents' reported discrepancy about whether the county's local guard members were personally presented a plaque.
Mayor Patty Woodby presented proclamations at the meeting recognizing Hampton High School and Happy Valley High School for recovery efforts after Hurricane Helene; her role in regional National Guard outreach was noted in the correspondence the commission received.
The commission accepted the letter into the record and took a ten-minute recess; members did not vote on additional action related to the plaque dispute at the April 20 meeting, but several commissioners and residents asked that staff confirm whether the local National Guard unit had been given a physical plaque or proclamation and report back at a future meeting.
