Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Workplace Violence topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Supporters cite rising ED violence; advocates warn penal change could criminalize psychiatric crisis
Summary
Witnesses were sharply split over SB667: hospitals, security trainers and the Health Care Workplace Safety Commission urged tougher penalties and protections for emergency department staff; disability and mental‑health advocates cautioned the bill risks penalizing people in medical or psychiatric crisis and urged data collection and non‑criminal interventions.
A lengthy public hearing on SB667 produced sharply divergent views about how best to protect emergency department and other healthcare staff from violence.
Sponsor Senator Tim Mcu framed the bill as correcting a gap: EMS and prehospital responders have enhanced statutory protections, but equivalent safeguards for hospital emergency staff were narrower. The bill would raise penalties in some circumstances using a "knowingly" standard intended to exclude people who lack culpable mental states.
Hospitals, security trainers, physicians and the Health Care Workplace Safety Commission presented data showing thousands of reported workplace‑violence events in recent fiscal years and described operational strain, staff injuries and recruitment/retention problems. They urged the legislation as part of a broader workplace‑safety strategy.
Opponents—including disability advocates, the ACLU, NAMI and family caregivers—argued that criminal penalties do not address root causes, that many incidents involve patients with dementia or acute psychiatric or medical crises, and that new felony charges risk detention of medically vulnerable people. Lawyers and advocates urged first to assess whether the 2023 warrantless‑arrest statute is being applied effectively and to invest in de‑escalation training, better ED psychiatric capacity, and non‑criminal workplace‑safety measures.
The committee heard recommendations ranging from enhanced training, staffing and dedicated psychiatric hold areas to improved reporting and data collection. The bill remained under consideration with no committee vote recorded during the session.
