Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Code Enforcement topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Magistrate gives Flamingo Street owner 30 days to submit permit materials; fines may follow
Summary
A Fort Myers Beach special magistrate granted property owner Michael Shoemaker 30 days to provide required engineering and product‑approval documents for a sunroom and patio permit, assessed $352.38 in administrative costs and warned daily fines (up to $250) will begin if the property remains non‑compliant after that period.
Monica Schmucker, the appointed special magistrate for Fort Myers Beach code‑enforcement hearings, gave property owner Michael Shoemaker 30 days to submit the engineering plans and Florida product approvals the town said are missing for a sunroom and patio at 130 Flamingo Street.
The order follows town testimony that Shoemaker received a notice of violation posted Jan. 22, 2026, a series of extensions and two permit rejections (Feb. 25 and March 9, 2026) because required documents had not been provided. Terry W., a town compliance officer, summarized exhibits the town entered into evidence — including photos, county property‑records screenshots and emails showing extension requests and rejection letters.
Shoemaker told the magistrate he needs more time because the materials take “at least 30 to 40 days” to obtain. Town staff responded they were willing to allow a 30‑day period. Magistrate Schmucker said she would issue an order giving the owner 30 days to submit the paperwork and warned: “if things don't happen within the time that's said ... you will begin to accrue fines” and that fines are daily and can be up to $250.
The magistrate also corrected and assessed the administrative cost for bringing the case: $352.38, which she placed on the record. The order states no daily fines will begin until after the 30‑day compliance period; the magistrate said she will set the fine start date in the written order if the owner fails to comply.
Why it matters: The magistrate's time‑limited order gives the owner a clear path to avoid escalating penalties, while the town preserves authority to assess daily fines and recover costs if compliance is not achieved.
The written order is expected within the week; the hearing calendar showed the next magistrate hearing is April 16.
