Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Employee Benefits topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
St. Cloud council approves switch to hybrid health plan with reference-based pricing to curb rising costs
Summary
After hearing options showing a projected 2.6–3.3% savings versus a 12.4% renewal increase, council voted to replace its current administrative services agreement and adopt a hybrid model (United Healthcare PO plus a reference-based ClaimDoc plan administered via UMR) effective Oct. 1, 2026; staff said the plan could lower many inpatient out-of-pocket costs but requires intensive employee education and provider outreach.
The City of St. Cloud voted to move its self-funded health plan to a new model that pairs a United Healthcare point-of-service (PO) option with a reference-based pricing (RBP) plan administered through ClaimDoc and UMR. Human resources director Justin Klesner and broker Danielle Bole (Brown & Brown) presented the three alternatives and recommended the hybrid option to avoid an estimated $1.2 million increase the city faced under the current renewal.
Danielle Bole summarized the rationale: hospitals’ billed charges and the escalation in commercial allowed amounts drive large increases in employer plan costs; ClaimDoc’s model pays a reference percentage of Medicare plus conducts line‑by‑line claim auditing, which the broker said historically reduces trend and eliminates excessive markups on facility claims. "The claim-audit piece is a huge saver as well. So instead of just paying the bill as it comes in, every single facility claim, whether $2,000 or $2 million, is line-by-line audited," Bole said.
Under the recommended design, employees would have a choice: a traditional PO network plan under United Healthcare (slightly tweaked from the city’s current plan) or the ClaimDoc RBP option that the broker described as richer on certain inpatient metrics but requiring provider onboarding. Bole said employer modeling shows a 2.6% budget decrease if roughly 70% of employees choose the RBP plan and a 3.3% decrease if 80% do — compared with a 12.4% increase if the city had kept the existing arrangement.
HR Director Justin Klesner emphasized the importance of a market-led education and onboarding campaign for providers: "Employees will either go to the online portal or sit one-on-one with us... ClaimDoc has 200 people who reach out to providers to explain how the plan works and they have a very high acceptance rate," he said. Council members requested that staff provide comprehensive outreach supports — including provider nomination and pre-enrollment verification — so employees know whether their clinicians will accept the plan before choosing policies.
Council approved a series of related documents: (a) a resolution authorizing the administrative-services agreement with UMR Inc. as TPA, (b) adoption of a reference-based pricing agreement with ClaimDoc/HealthScope Benefits, and (c) termination of the city’s existing ASO with Signet Healthcare (effective October 1, 2026). The council voted 4‑0 to adopt the plan change and the related contract actions.
What this means for employees: Staff and the broker said employees who elect the ClaimDoc plan could see substantially lower payroll contributions and more predictable inpatient costs — with examples like an inclusive $500 inpatient facility fee on some services — but the model requires proactive provider outreach and an implementation team to help employees nominate providers and resolve billing questions.
Provenance: Full presentation and lengthy Q&A occurred in the council action portion of the meeting (SEG 3966–SEG 5051).
