Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Personnel Substitutes topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Punxsutawney Area SD board approves awarding substitute-services RFP to ESS, will finalize sub rates
Summary
The board approved awarding an RFP for substitute-services support to ESS and asked staff to return with finalized sub-rate details; the discussion focused on proposed vendor markup, the district's current flat sub rate (listed in the transcript as 850 per hour), pension withholding and the risk that outside subs could be paid more than current employees.
The Punxsutawney Area School District board voted to award its substitute-services RFP to ESS and directed staff to finalize substitute pay rates before the vendor begins service.
Board members engaged in extended discussion before the vote about the agencyproposal and its implications. Members noted ESSused starting-rate figures in its proposal and that the vendorpositioned a roughly 22% markup on its internal pay calculations. Several board members expressed concern that, unless the board sets a district flat rate for pay, long-term substitutes supplied by a vendor could end up earning more than employees who hold the same positions on the district payroll.
Staff told the board that the district currently uses a flat sub rate referenced in the meeting transcript as "850" per hour and that the board can set the district sub rate in its contract with ESS; staff said the vendor will apply its percentage on top of any board-set pay. The transcript also notes an 8.5% pension withholding for substitutes who reach certain service thresholds, which complicates net pay comparisons between district employees and vendor-provided subs.
Board members discussed operational benefits ESS could provide, including on-site hiring events, broader candidate reach and potential on-site training and safety programs, balanced against concerns about long-term pay disparities and the effect on current employees' morale and pay scale.
The board approved items one through six in personnel business, including awarding the RFP to ESS for substitute services, with the explicit caveat that the board will finalize sub rates later. Staff said the implementation would not begin until July 1 for the next school year so the board has time to set rates and contract details.
Board members said they will revisit rates if the arrangement fails to deliver the needed subs.
