Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the School Consolidation topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Staff recommend keeping Clifton open as Monrovia Unified considers middle-school consolidation
Summary
District staff recommended keeping Clifton Middle School as the single consolidated campus after presenting facility, enrollment and equity analyses; trustees and community members raised transportation, parking and equity concerns and the board will vote Dec. 17.
District staff on Wednesday presented a recommendation to consolidate Monrovia Unified’s two middle schools into a single campus and keep Clifton Middle School open, citing declining enrollment and projected budget savings needed to meet a county-mandated $6.2 million fiscal stabilization target.
The recommendation followed months of mapping, facility comparisons and analysis of operating costs, site capacity and environmental justice data. Superintendent Paula Hart Roes told trustees the combination is “necessary long-term” given a projected 2% annual enrollment decline and uneven modernization eligibility at the two campuses.
Why it matters: the consolidation would reassign students and staff, reshape transportation routes and change how the district uses state modernization funds. Staff said the move would reduce ongoing costs and help preserve programs districtwide as enrollments shrink.
What staff presented: district analysts showed geolocated student addresses and 1.5-mile radius maps to estimate transportation needs and compared ancillary spaces and restroom access. They reported Santa Fe’s student population has a higher share of students on free and reduced-price meals (81% by percentage), but Clifton’s raw counts and state funding eligibility differ; as presented, Clifton currently shows higher projected state modernization eligibility.
Key community concerns: a string of public commenters, including Nancy Gonzalez (community liaison at Santa Fe Middle School), urged trustees to secure reliable transportation for students if a consolidation proceeds. Gonzalez said consistent transit is necessary for timely arrival, after-school participation and equitable access to extracurriculars. Parent Christina Bragg and other speakers recommended keeping Clifton open, stressing its central location and role in the city center.
District response on buses: staff said the transportation office has analyzed routes and, with an additional bus driver already hired, believes rerouting and a modest operational cost could provide rides for students from farther reaches of the district. Administrators cautioned, however, that a shortage of drivers could force tradeoffs on route timing and frequency; trustees asked staff to model costs and service options in detail.
Facilities and funding notes: staff noted differences in modernization eligibility and accessibility constraints at both campuses. They reported Santa Fe may require an elevator (estimated roughly $880,000–$900,000) to make upper-level classrooms accessible, while Clifton’s classrooms were described as usable now. Staff also flagged that newly available housing in the district has so far generated very few new students (34 of 1,360 units), complicating near-term enrollment projections.
Trustees’ view and next steps: trustees and staff emphasized this is a recommendation, not a final decision. The board said it will continue public outreach, collect transportation surveys of families, consult with the City on traffic and parking impacts, and produce a transition plan (January–June) if a consolidation is approved. A final board decision is scheduled for Dec. 17.
What to watch: follow-up materials the board requested include detailed transportation-cost scenarios, parking and drop-off plans for Clifton, and a stakeholder transition timeline that covers staffing, student assignments and extracurricular participation.
