Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Secondhand Retail topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Salvation Army seeks reuse of vacant industrial building for a large donation store; commissioners raise spot‑zoning and process questions
Summary
The Salvation Army proposed converting a vacant office/industrial building at 4200 76th St W into an 18,000 sq ft retail family store with a 9,000 sq ft warehouse and donation drop‑off; commissioners welcomed the social benefits but flagged a city ordinance that limits secondhand stores to 2,500 sq ft and urged staff to analyze zoning, comprehensive‑plan and spot‑zoning implications before any formal application.
The Salvation Army asked the Edina Planning Commission on Jan. 14 for early feedback on a sketch plan to convert a vacant office/industrial building on 76th Street into a donation‑funded family store and warehouse operation. Applicant representatives described the store as roughly 18,000 square feet of retail floor area with a 9,000 square‑foot warehouse and a production/processing area to sort donations. The project would operate a drive‑through donation center and an in‑store retail floor selling clothing (about 50–60% of sales), household goods and furniture; the proposed donation hours are 9 a.m. to 9 p.m.
Tom Canfield of the Salvation Army’s Adult Rehabilitation Center described the program: revenues from thrift retail fund long‑term residential rehabilitation for individuals with substance‑use disorders; the organization self‑funds the program through store sales and processing rather than relying on government support. Joe Becker, the applicant’s consultant, said the organization expects roughly 50 donor vehicles per day on average and that peak donation centers can see up to ~500 donors per week. The team said the building size matches the Salvation Army’s operating model because they process thousands of items daily and prefer colocating sorting/production and retail to reduce transportation costs.
City staff and commissioners identified two principal regulatory hurdles. First, a city ordinance currently restricts secondhand stores larger than 2,500 square feet; second, the parcel is in a Planned Industrial (P) district guided in the comprehensive plan for office and multifamily residential, and the comprehensive‑plan guidance does not list retail as a primary use in that land‑use category. Staff said options include (a) amend the ordinance to remove the 2,500‑square‑foot cap or allow secondhand stores of any size in commercial districts, (b) rezone the parcel to a commercial district, and/or (c) amend the comprehensive plan to allow retail as a primary use in the area — each option carries broader policy consequences and potential spot‑zoning concerns.
Commissioners broadly praised the Salvation Army’s community benefit, job‑creation and sustainable reuse of a vacant building, but they were split on the technical path forward. Several commissioners favored removing the 2,500‑square‑foot cap for secondhand retail and examining broader district‑level changes as part of the city’s upcoming comprehensive‑plan update rather than approving a one‑off spot rezoning. Others warned that allowing larger retail uses in the industrial/office area without careful policy work could create unintended demand for similar retail uses in adjoining properties, changing the character and economic dynamics of the district. Staff recommended further analysis to quantify potential impacts and to identify the cleanest regulatory path that avoids ad‑hoc spot zoning.
No vote or formal action was taken. Commissioners asked staff to return with options and analysis that outline consequences of code or plan changes and to coordinate this work with the city’s comprehensive‑plan update so policy changes are considered in a broader district context.
