Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Policy Proposals topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Chair Yates proposes federal-style sentence reductions and guideline clarifications; bylaws motion pulled for revision
Summary
Chair Chris Yates proposed initial reforms including reductions for substantial assistance and acceptance of responsibility, and technical clarifications to offense-variable scoring and prior-record columns; a motion to adopt bylaws was withdrawn for edits and a vice chair was named.
At the Michigan Sentencing Commission's inaugural meeting, Chair Judge Chris Yates put several policy ideas on the table as starting points for the commission's work and said he would create a subcommittee to vet specifics.
Yates proposed two reductions modeled on the federal system: a sentence reduction for defendants who provide "substantial assistance" to law enforcement, and a reduction for early acceptance of responsibility for defendants who plead guilty and express remorse. "My first two proposals come directly from the federal sentencing guidelines," he said, adding the commission would discuss whether prosecutors should be the gatekeepers for such reductions or whether courts could act on their own.
Yates also identified persistent technical problems he said drive appellate reversals: the scoring of offense variables 11, 12 and 13; the application of OV19 (threats to penal institutions or courts); and the relatively low cutoff for the highest prior-record-variable (PRV) column at 75 points. He suggested adding two PRV columns to better differentiate defendants with very long criminal histories and reduce reliance on upward departures.
Yates said these are agenda starters and that he will appoint a guideline-recommendations subcommittee of judges, prosecutors and defense attorneys to do the detailed drafting and analysis.
Separately, the chair introduced proposed bylaws prepared by staff and asked for a motion to approve. Prosecutor Karen McDonald moved to approve the bylaws and Judge Pam Lightboat seconded, but members raised concerns that the bylaws' duties language read as mostly reactive to the legislature and did not explicitly reference rehabilitation; after discussion Prosecutor McDonald withdrew the motion so staff could revise the language and return it at a later meeting.
Yates announced his selection of Judge Pam Lightboat as vice chair; Lightboat accepted. The commission tentatively scheduled additional meetings in June, September and November and adjourned after confirming reimbursement procedures for mileage and parking.
