Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Short Term Rentals topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Planning commission approves short-term rental at 1351 El Bonita Court
Summary
The Saint Helena Planning Commission unanimously approved a staff‑recommended short‑term rental permit for a one‑bedroom attached unit at 1351 El Bonita Court after a staff presentation, clarifying questions about notice, and supportive public comment.
The Saint Helena Planning Commission voted unanimously to approve a short‑term rental permit for an attached one‑bedroom, one‑bath unit at 1351 El Bonita Court following a staff recommendation and public comment.
Staff presented the application and said the proposed unit — approximately 400 square feet and accessed from the side yard — includes two on‑site tandem parking spaces that meet city requirements. The staff report concluded the project meets the six findings required for approval under the Saint Helena Municipal Code and recommended approval; staff also recommended a categorical exemption under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) Guidelines section 15061(b)(3). A staff member told the commission, "Staff recommends approving the short‑term rental permit at 1351 El Bonita Court."
The applicant, Mark Larson, identified himself at the hearing as the property owner and said he had no objections to the application. "I don't really have any comments unless there's any opposition," he said. A nearby resident, Kim K, who said she lives behind the property, spoke in support and asked clarifying questions about the unit configuration and past use; she said she was not opposed to the proposal.
Commissioners asked how adjacent owners were notified and whether returned mail and mailed comments are retained. A staff member confirmed notices were mailed within the standard 300‑foot radius, that any returned mail or written comments are kept with the project record, and that staff had not received written public comments before the hearing.
After deliberation, a commissioner moved to approve the staff recommendation, including the CEQA categorical exemption; the motion was seconded and carried on a roll‑call vote. Commissioner Lopez voted yes; Commissioner Koval voted yes; Chair Warner voted yes.
The permit will allow short‑term rental operation of the attached unit; staff and commissioners said the project is compatible with the neighborhood and expected to generate transient occupancy tax revenue. The record shows the permit number was transcribed inconsistently in the hearing record and is not specified here.
