Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Case Review Votes topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
CPRC adopts working-group recommendations on multiple case reviews and re-elects chair
Summary
At its May 15 meeting the CPRC adopted recommendations from its three working groups on several closed cases — including an ICE-related detention review and a contested social-media complaint — and unanimously re-elected Carlos Graves as chair and Laura Cortes Franco as vice chair.
The Community Police Review Commission on May 15 voted to adopt multiple working-group recommendations after presentations by its three review groups and later unanimously re‑elected its leadership.
Working Group A summarized several closed cases; among them, case 2092 involved a firearms discharge and Taser deployment, and the group reported agreement with APO and internal affairs findings that did not sustain policy violations in that file. The commission voted to adopt Working Group A's recommendations.
Working Group B presented case APO202034, an incident involving immigration-status inquiries and ICE detainer requests. The group found some policy violations tied to confusion over changing general orders but recommended a disposition focused on training and dissemination of clearer guidance rather than punitive discipline. Commissioners discussed chain-of-command issues and whether supervisors should carry greater responsibility when multiple officers repeat the same practice; the commission adopted the working-group recommendation.
Working Group C reviewed two cases including an external complaint alleging misconduct by an officer who posted videos on social media in uniform and in a marked APD vehicle. Working Group C concluded prohibited-speech and conduct policies were violated (citing general orders that prohibit department-identifying conduct on personal accounts and conduct that brings discredit to the department) and recommended 1'to' days suspension. APO recommended 1'to' days suspension; APD recommended training. Commissioners said the case illustrates a persistent operational challenge: the CPRC sometimes receives cases after APD has already issued discipline, limiting the commission's ability to influence dispositions. The commission voted to adopt Working Group C's recommendation and requested further briefings from APD/internal affairs to explain their disciplinary rationale in cases where outcomes diverge.
The commission then accepted a motion to re-nominate and re-elect Carlos Graves as chair and Laura Cortes Franco as vice chair; the vote was unanimous.
Commissioners recorded a desire to improve case-timing processes, to request redacted briefings from internal affairs when appropriate, and to explore proactive release of body-worn camera footage when permitted by legal constraints. The commission agreed to place a dashboard demonstration on the June agenda.
