Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the International Education topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Board member recounts Germany school-study trip; highlights funding and apprenticeship differences
Summary
Mrs. Turner reported on a PSBA‑affiliated study visit to Germany, noting that in visited states "a third of their state budget goes to education," teachers are state employees, and apprenticeships and employer‑led vocational pathways are more extensive than in the U.S.
Board member Mrs. Turner delivered a detailed account of a week‑long study trip to Germany that she attended with other Pennsylvania educators and legislators. Turner said the delegation met with state education ministers and visited a variety of schools and education centers, and she highlighted structural contrasts with U.S. districts.
"A third of their state budget goes to education," Turner said, adding that in the German model teachers are state employees and local municipalities fund facilities and operations. She described meeting with a state minister and a host of officials and noted that the German system offers distinct secondary tracks (including vocational and academic paths) and requires certain businesses to provide apprenticeships.
Turner described school visits that showed broad use of vocational pathways, hands‑on 'comprehensive school' models, and early language instruction; she also said some schools integrate religion with roughly 10% church funding in particular institutions. The delegation observed that apprenticeships can lead directly to well‑paid careers without college; Turner estimated a post‑apprenticeship chemical‑engineering wage equivalent to about $70,000 in U.S. dollars.
Board members asked whether German educators saw U.S. security concerns differently; Turner said they were aware of U.S. issues but pointed to large cultural and statistical differences: U.S. schools have had many more shootings in recent periods than Germany. Several board members drew practical takeaways—pay scales and teacher recruitment are policy levers Germany is using to address shortages, Turner said.
Turner concluded that while several German practices would be hard to transplant directly to York Suburban, the trip produced ideas about staffing models, vocational partnerships and curriculum organization the district could consider.
