Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Public Facility And Infrastructure topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Commission pauses decision on Minnehaha site and alley relocation after nearby businesses warn of delivery and access problems
Summary
The Planning Commission continued the multi‑part Minnehaha/Snelling application one cycle (to June 8) after Hook and Ladder theater and other businesses objected to vacating and relocating an alley segment that they say is critical for deliveries and handicap access; staff and Public Works said the design meets standard turning radii but committed to additional engagement.
A multi‑part redevelopment to convert the former 3rd Precinct building at 3000 Minnehaha Avenue into a consolidated Elections & Voter Services (EVS) early vote center, which would reconfigure parcels and relocate a short east‑west alley segment, was continued one cycle by the Planning Commission on May 18 to allow additional design coordination with adjacent businesses.
Andrew Frentz, staff, described the project: a two‑story, roughly 16,800 sq. ft. addition, an alley vacation and replat that would move the alley about 75 feet to enlarge the northern parcel, rezonings for differing portions of the site, and required site plan review and a conditional use permit for EVS. Staff recommended approval of the CUP, site plan review and preliminary plat to the commission and recommended the rezonings and alley vacation to City Council.
Multiple business owners and nonprofit representatives, including Christine Smith (owner of the building that houses Hook and Ladder) and Hook and Ladder staff, said they were not adequately consulted about the alley relocation and warned the proposed configuration would disrupt deliveries, handicap access and operations. "If you came through and cut this off and do this plan ... that will be the last of the death of 1,000 cuts," Christine Smith said, arguing the loss of alley access could imperil the nonprofit's financial viability. A Hook and Ladder representative said the smallest delivery vehicles the venue sees are 42 feet, contradicting staff's reference to 30‑foot box‑truck design vehicles.
Staff and Public Works representatives responded that the alley design was reviewed to accommodate typical public‑works design vehicles — garbage trucks, snow‑removal equipment and 30‑foot box trucks — and that the technical review considered turning diagrams; larger truck deliveries are anticipated to occur in the street where alleys are not designed for semis. Project manager Dr. Maya (Property Services) said the private driveway north of the Hook and Ladder can accommodate vehicles up to 45 feet in their design, and said Property Services is open to further conversations.
Commissioners debated options including denial, sending items to council without a recommendation, or approving parts of the application and denying others. Several commissioners urged more targeted engagement with affected businesses to find alternatives such as easements or modest design changes to preserve existing access. Commissioner Shepherd moved to continue the item one cycle to June 8 so applicants and neighboring businesses could pursue design changes; the motion carried by voice vote and the item was continued.
Next steps: The applicant agreed to continue conversations and the item will return to the Planning Commission on June 8. The rezonings and the alley vacation are legislative actions that will go to City Council; the CUP and site‑plan items remain quasi‑judicial and could be the subject of findings or appeals.
