Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Short Term Rentals topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Board grants short‑term rental exception after applicant cites medical and notification issues
Summary
After staff recommended denial because the request would exceed the neighborhood STR cap, the Board of Adjustment granted Nathan Lang a Type‑2 short‑term rental exception at 647 Lee Street following testimony about a missed renewal and family medical circumstances; the motion passed 9–1.
The Board of Adjustment granted a Type‑2 short‑term rental special exception for property owner Nathan Lang at 647 Lee Street after a contested hearing in which staff recommended denial and neighbors and the applicant described conflicting notices and personal hardship.
Juan Álvarez, planner with Development Services, told commissioners that the application would push the block’s Type‑2 STR density above the 12.5% limit (staff reported the block would reach about 14% if approved) and that staff recommended denial. Alvarez also reviewed his office’s outreach: 31 notices were mailed and staff documented past enforcement contacts.
Applicant Nathan Lang responded that he has operated a short‑term rental for years and that a renewal was missed due to personal and family health events; he told the board he had cameras, house rules, and practices to reduce neighborhood impacts. Resident May Fernández spoke in support, noting rising property taxes and saying the owner should be allowed to supplement income.
Commissioners questioned the notification process and whether the applicant had been given adequate advance warning about unpaid taxes and renewal timelines. Several commissioners emphasized the need for operators to know their tax reporting responsibilities; staff said the city sends multiple notices (mail and email) and that financial records show recent tax payments.
After discussion Commissioner Mana moved to grant the exception on the grounds of evidence of mitigating circumstances and neighborhood support; the motion passed 9–1. The minutes show Commissioner Dean voted no. The board directed staff to verify outstanding tax payments and to follow up with the applicant on remaining compliance steps.
Why this matters: granting the exception increases the number of Type‑2 short‑term rentals on the block beyond the stated density limit, a decision that may affect neighbors and city enforcement priorities. Commissioners emphasized the distinctions between administrative enforcement and discretionary relief and asked staff to tighten outreach and clarity about post‑approval tax and reporting obligations.
Next steps: Staff will verify tax payments and compliance and the applicant must comply with any remaining licensing and reporting requirements.
