Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Development Approval topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Commission approves 19,000‑sq‑ft Newport Birch medical building with 7‑space parking waiver
Summary
The Planning Commission approved a proposed ~19,000 sq ft medical office building at 20071 Birch Street with a minor 7‑space parking waiver and conditions; neighbors raised concerns about potential overflow into adjacent lots.
The Newport Beach Planning Commission unanimously approved May 21 a proposal to build a roughly 19,000‑square‑foot medical office building at 20071 Birch Street, granting a minor parking waiver and adopting conditions the staff said would limit certain high‑intensity medical uses.
Staff said the property sits in the Santa Ana Heights specific plan’s Business Park District and requires a minor site development review and minor use permit. The application proposes 89 parking spaces where code requires 96, which staff characterized as a 7‑space (7.2%) waiver enabled by the applicant providing one on‑site pickup/drop‑off space and bicycle parking. Staff also reported a traffic study estimating a net increase of about 643 average daily trips from the prior single‑family residence that occupied the lot.
Neighbor Diane Hornby, property manager for a nearby office building, said overflow parking already affects adjacent lots and urged caution before granting the waiver. “I would just respectfully ask that the commission considers the importance of waiving and not waiving the spots that they're requesting to be waived,” she said.
Applicant Fred Alegband of ACS Development Group and Architect Giselle Walter said they concurred with staff recommendations and said their experience managing similar medical office properties suggested the proposed parking would be workable; they pledged to cooperate with the city if mitigation is needed.
Commissioners pressed staff on how the code’s objective waivers would be applied and whether mitigation measures would be required if spillover occurred. Staff said the municipal code provides administrative flexibility (director/zoning administrator authority with objective criteria) and that the director could require additional mitigation if parking spillover becomes a nuisance. The project’s conditions also prohibit future conversion of the building to a hospital or urgent care facility.
A motion to approve the project as presented passed unanimously; staff will return any required follow‑up if parking problems emerge or additional mitigation is recommended.
