Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Administrative Law topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
House passes bill allowing legislative intervention in agency judicial review (Senate file 2039)
Summary
The House voted to pass Senate file 2039 after receding on its amendment H8286; the bill provides for intervention by members of the General Assembly in judicial-review proceedings under the Iowa Administrative Procedure Act. Opponents warned it invites partisan intrusion into the judiciary.
The House passed Senate file 2039, a bill that would permit members of the General Assembly to intervene in proceedings for judicial review of agency actions under the Iowa Administrative Procedure Act, after a motion that the House recede on its amendment H8286.
The representative from Crawford moved that the House recede on its amendment H8286 and urged members to vote yes on the underlying Senate file 2039. Representative Weick Nadal spoke in opposition, calling the bill "an unwarranted political intrusion into the judicial branch" that could compromise constitutional rights and invite partisan participation in judicial processes.
Following discussion and the sponsor's motion, the clerk conducted a machine vote. The clerk announced the result as 59 ayes, 25 noes and 16 absent/not voting; the clerk declared the bill received a constitutional majority and the title was agreed to.
Floor remarks centered on the balance between legislative oversight and preserving judicial independence; no amendments or modifications were recorded during the floor action that concluded with passage in the House.
