Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Open Meetings topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Council Adopts Brown Act Teleconference Policy Updates; Mayor Pro Tem Rotation Rule Draws 3–2 Vote
Summary
Council approved updates to policy 121‑11 to comply with SB 707 teleconference rules and meeting conduct, including a new rotational mayor pro tem appointment rule; the broader policy passed 3‑2 after debate over free‑speech limits and sign restrictions.
The San Clemente City Council adopted updates to its meeting and teleconference policy June 2 to comply with Senate Bill 707 and to clarify rules for remote participation and conduct at city council meetings.
The proposed changes included procedures for remote public comment, mayor authority to rule on off‑topic remarks, and a paragraph restricting large placards or banners that block views or disrupt conduct in the chamber. A contested provision (item 4.3.1) establishes rotational appointment of the mayor pro tem to promote predictability and remove behind‑the‑scenes maneuvering.
Public commenters and council members expressed concerns about potential suppression of free speech, content‑based restrictions on addressing staff versus the council, and unclear language about signage. Amanda Kinttonia warned the rules might suppress free speech during remote comments; Council member Cabraw and another council member opposed binding mayor pro tem rotation by policy, arguing selection should be made case‑by‑case. Supporters said the updates give the mayor tools to address problems that have arisen with teleconferenced participation in other cities and increase transparency.
After debate and a proposed friendly amendment discussion about clarifying language on signs, the council adopted the policy by a 3‑2 vote, with Mayor Prom Nobel and Council member Cabraw recorded as dissenting votes on the motion.
Next steps: staff will implement the updated policy and prepare clarifying language where necessary; council asked the city attorney and staff to refine banner/sign wording for future review.
