After heated debate, New Hartford passes 3‑term limit local law for supervisor and council seats

The New Hartford Town Board adopted a local law on June 3 that limits consecutive service for the town supervisor and town council members to three consecutive terms (a 12‑year cap), after an hour‑plus of testimony and debate.

Board members opened a public hearing that drew both supporters and opponents. Former long‑time board member Richard Woodland spoke in favor of term limits to encourage turnover and new voices, suggesting an eight‑year cap could be appropriate. Other residents and board members urged caution, arguing continuity and voter choice favor no limits. Several council members spoke at length about the challenges potential challengers face when running against long‑time incumbents and the tradeoffs between continuity and opportunity for new leaders.

After discussion of alternatives (two‑term/8‑year versus three‑term/12‑year options), Councilman Teehan moved to adopt the local law as drafted with three consecutive terms. The motion was seconded and a roll call followed. The board recorded a majority vote in favor with several members dissenting. Town Attorney Herb Colley advised that the local law defines consecutive terms as service without interruption and that a break in service of at least two full terms resets eligibility.

The board agreed to finalize the drafting and recordation steps needed to make the local law effective and directed staff to circulate the final ordinance text and next administrative steps to the public.