Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Ordinance 2026 12 topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Debate over making Kirkwood Avenue permanently car‑free intensifies; council delays vote pending Transportation Commission review
Summary
Ordinance 2026‑12, which would codify a seasonal car‑free schedule for multiple Kirkwood Avenue blocks to support outdoor dining and pedestrian activity, drew lengthy debate and split public input: downtown businesses and the Chamber urged caution, citing parking and management burdens, while commissions and residents urged permanent pedestrianization and investment. The council postponed final action to June 10 to allow the Transportation Commission to review and staff to provide fiscal and operational details.
Council members spent the meeting’s longest block discussing Ordinance 2026‑12, a proposed change to Title 15 that would codify a seasonal schedule closing specified blocks of Kirkwood Avenue to motor vehicles to create a permanent pedestrianized corridor.
Sponsors said codifying a predictable seasonal closure would encourage businesses to invest in patio infrastructure and help make downtown more vibrant. Council Member Daly highlighted economic arguments tied to a forthcoming convention center expansion and IU event dates and said a walkable Kirkwood could be a downtown anchor.
Opponents included downtown business owners and the Greater Bloomington Chamber of Commerce, who warned the ordinance—especially if implemented without an operating plan and funding—could harm parking turnover, limit access for employees and customers and impose management responsibilities (trash, sanitation, enforcement) on the city and businesses. Hartzell’s Ice Cream co‑owner Hillilary Martell said last summer’s closure left many picnic tables empty and exacerbated parking scarcity when students are in session.
Commissions and some residents urged bolder action: the Commission on Sustainability and Resilience recommended continuing seasonal closures at a minimum and studying permanent year‑round closure models used successfully in other college towns; advocates urged copying successful elements from places such as Burlington or Boulder while adapting for Bloomington’s size and demographics.
City staff and the deputy mayor cautioned that Bloomington differs in budget, MSA size, student share of population and public safety resources from other pedestrianized downtowns, and emphasized that a corridor study and funding plan are needed to avoid a poorly managed outcome. The city’s Transportation Commission had not yet completed a statutory review at the time of the meeting; the council opted to postpone a final vote until June 10 to allow that advisory review and to give staff time to prepare fiscal and operational clarifications.
Outcome: Motion to postpone carried; sponsors and staff signaled they will return with an amendment (including a proposed effective date) and additional implementation details.
