Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Certificate Of Appropriateness topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Joplin Historic Preservation Commission approves certificate of appropriateness for 612 West U Street
Summary
The commission approved a certificate of appropriateness for 612 West U Street after staff recommended the proposal, citing materials that replicate historic shingles and noting ADA constraints that guide the choice of an alternate entrance; the owner will pursue a separate Planning & Zoning special use permit.
The Joplin Historic Preservation Commission on May 19 approved a certificate of appropriateness for 612 West U Street, clearing a preservation review step so the owner can pursue related permitting.
Staff told the commission the building retains relatively high integrity despite limited decorative elements and prior alterations. The applicant proposed an engineered PVC shingle that staff said closely replicates the original wood shake appearance; staff described the product as “almost indistinguishable” from historic shingles while acknowledging it will age differently. The report noted existing inappropriate vinyl siding on the sides of the building and a later greenhouse addition on the west side; staff recommended approval but said the commission would review siding removal if and when that work occurs.
Commission staff emphasized ADA constraints in the design decision, saying an accessible route through the greenhouse addition may be the least disruptive option because altering the primary storefront would require major interior changes. "Making a building accessible does trump historic preservation," staff said, while adding that the commission seeks alternatives that minimize harm to historic fabric.
Members asked about historic photos and shingle brands and heard public comments supporting the proposed roofing product. After discussion a motion to approve the certificate of appropriateness was made, seconded and approved by voice vote with no opposition recorded.
The owner will next pursue a special use permit and any Planning & Zoning review required for the change of use; the commission noted that those processes are separate from this certificate review and may impose additional conditions.
The commission moved to other agenda items after the vote.
