Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Education Technology topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Berwick Area SD debates one‑to‑one iPads for kindergartners amid handwriting concerns
Summary
District staff presented teacher survey data showing kindergarten device use is about 15–30 minutes a day and recommended ordering replacement iPads; board members and parents debated one‑to‑one vs. classroom carts, screen time, handwriting impact and device lifespan as staff said a July planning item will return for a formal decision.
A presenter for Berwick Area SD told the board the district’s teachers report using kindergarten devices between about 15 and 30 minutes a day and that many instructional programs and benchmark screeners are delivered online, which would require either classroom devices or one‑to‑one hardware.
“The teachers said they use technology in the kindergarten classroom somewhere between 15 and 30 minutes a day,” the presenter said, and recommended the board clarify whether to replace kindergarten devices with iPads next year so ordering and planning can proceed.
Board members, staff and members of the public raised concerns about handwriting, screen time and device management. One parent thanked teachers and urged the board to ensure policies that respect all students; other speakers said they had observed children using devices as brief instructional tools and not as a substitute for handwriting practice.
Participants discussed tradeoffs: a one‑to‑one model keeps devices in the classroom daily and supports personalization, but devices taken home raise questions about loss and damage; a cart or classroom set reduces home use but limits immediate access. Board members asked about device lifespan — staff estimated roughly five years — and about insurance and how breakage claims are handled.
Several board members said they favored keeping one‑to‑one devices for kindergarten, while others urged caution and asked staff to return with a concrete model and cost estimates. The presenter said staff will bring a planning item to the July meeting so the board can decide whether to continue one‑to‑one or move to classroom sets.
The discussion did not include a final vote on procurement; staff said they need board direction to proceed with purchasing plans and ordering timelines.
