Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Accessibility topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Veteran urges Brownwood to adopt CART captioning after hearing Zoom captions deemed insufficient
Summary
A veteran who lost his hearing urged Brownwood officials to standardize ADA accommodations and provide CART captioning rather than Zoom captions, saying the latter is less accurate; he referenced a demand letter but said he was not seeking further action at the meeting.
Chaleb Pommells, a veteran who said he lost his hearing while serving in the military, told the Brownwood City Council on April 28 that the city’s current meeting captioning options fall short and urged a standardized approach to accommodation requests. "Zoom captions are already available, but they are not as accurate as CART services," Pommells said, demonstrating an iPad with captioning during his public comment.
Pommells said he provided 24-hour notice as the meeting agenda requests and followed up with the City Attorney, and that he submitted a demand letter indicating he would pursue the matter further if CART services were not provided. He suggested the city form a review committee to evaluate accommodation requests and develop a standardized policy for future meetings.
Mayor Stephen E. Haynes asked whether Pommells sought additional action from the council; Pommells replied that he was not seeking any further action at that time. The council did not take action during the meeting on the request.
The exchange highlighted a gap between available captioning tools and the needs of attendees who rely on real-time, verbatim captioning. Pommells’ account identifies CART (Communication Access Realtime Translation) as the preferred service for accuracy; he contrasted CART with automated Zoom captions and said the latter can introduce errors that matter in civic proceedings.
Next steps were not announced at the meeting; the city did not state a timeline for reviewing accommodation policies.
