Coalition of families asks New Albany council to commission independent review of theater program

An attorney for a parent coalition asked the New Albany City Council on June 16 to commission an independent review into complaints about the city's theater program and the treatment of teacher Melissa Gould.

Gregory Vincent, who identified himself as an attorney representing more than 400 New Albany parents, students, alumni and community members, told council his office has received “statements from parents who believe their students were used as examples of dissatisfaction” and that some advocacy efforts may have mischaracterized families' views. "The coalition expects the New Albany City Council to initiate an independent review of these concerns and provide a report to the community before the council's next regular scheduled meeting," Vincent said.

Vincent outlined allegations that included perceptions of conflicts of interest and unequal access or influence in decision-making related to the theater program, and asked council to explain how decisions were made. He said the coalition also received evidence describing the positive impact of the theater program and the leadership of Melissa Gould.

In a separate public comment, Deborah Cogan, a New Albany resident, urged civility in public debate about the program: "Healthy communities are not defined by the absence of disagreement. They are defined by how respectfully they navigate it," she said.

Council did not take formal action on Vincent's request during the meeting. City staff and council members did not offer a timeline or commit to opening an independent inquiry on the record at the June 16 session; Vincent asked for a report before the next regular meeting.

What happened next: Council received the request during the public-comment portion of the meeting and did not put the matter on the agenda for action that night. Officials present did not dispute the coalition's request but also did not announce a process or timeline for an independent review during the meeting.

Why it matters: The request asks an elected body to authorize an independent examination of allegations that could involve elected officials, school administrators and community advocates. Council will decide whether to pursue a formal review, which could prompt a separate fact-finding process and public reporting.

Speakers (attributed quotes): Gregory Vincent (attorney representing a coalition of parents and alumni); Deborah Cogan (resident).

Notes: The coalition's handout was referenced at the meeting and Vincent said copies were available. The transcript does not show a council vote or staff commitment to order an independent review at the June 16 meeting.