Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Historic Preservation topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Waukesha Landmarks Commission approves roof replacement at 311 McCall Street
Summary
The commission approved a certificate of appropriateness for a roof replacement at 311 McCall Street, allowing Atlas Pinnacle Impact shingles in a pewter color; the property owner presented samples and commissioners voted to approve the request.
The Waukesha City Landmarks Commission approved a certificate of appropriateness on March 25 for a roof replacement at 311 McCall Street in the McCall Street historic district.
Staff described the proposal as a replacement of an existing gray three‑tab shingled roof with Atlas Pinnacle Impact shingles in a pewter color and standard flashing and ventilation work. "They'll be replacing the roof, new shingles will be Atlas Pinnacle Impact Pewter Color," staff said, noting the Atlas Pinnacle line had not previously appeared on the commission's approved materials list but appears visually compatible.
Property owner Wendy Mueller brought physical samples and told the commission: "I did bring in some samples if you'd like to see them." She said the Atlas Pinnacle was the option she preferred because it offered better value for the price. After a short discussion the chair moved to approve the shingle request "as presented"; a commissioner seconded the motion and the commission voted in favor.
The vote was taken by voice; commissioners who were called and recorded as voting "Aye" included Marty Larson, Carmen Delapaz, Matt Redzik, Aaron Spencer and Elizabeth Molson. The certificate of appropriateness was approved and the applicant may proceed with the work, subject to any building‑department permits and the usual inspection process.
The approval does not change the commission's materials list automatically; staff noted the Atlas Pinnacle line had not previously been approved and indicated the item was brought to the body because the material appeared compatible. Staff also reminded property owners that repair grants are awarded only after signed contracts and confirmation of available federal funds.
The commission's next steps on related preservation programs include finalizing the 2025 paint‑and‑repair grant process once grant contracts and federal funding are confirmed.
