Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Public Safety topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Des Moines council weighs public-safety trade-offs: neighborhood cops, fire recruits and a possible $6M dispatch consolidation
Summary
Council members heard that proposed reductions to neighborhood-based policing and other public-safety options could reduce visible policing and slow response or investigative capacity; staff also flagged a multi-jurisdictional dispatch consolidation that could save millions but would take years and must preserve current technology and staffing levels.
Chief of Police Mike McTar told the council that reducing the neighborhood-based service delivery (NBSD) team would remove the dedicated officers councilmembers and neighborhoods rely on for problem-solving, civil-issue follow-up and local transparency. "You would see the neighborhood officers go away," the chief said, describing the effect of staffing cuts on community engagement and on the department’s ability to provide tailored neighborhood information.
Police leadership and council members urged staff to present more options and division-level impacts rather than a single NBSD cut, in part because policing already consumes roughly one-third of the general fund and the department faces greater documentation and call-complexity burdens than in previous decades.
On the fire side, staff presented a recurring "certified-only" recruit model that favors hiring paramedic- or EMT-certified candidates who complete academy requirements faster. Assistant Fire Chief Brian Davis said certified hires "get to the street sooner," which reduces some training time and related payroll overlap, but council members noted the trade-off could reduce hiring from within the city and alter long-term workforce development.
A separate, high-profile option staff flagged is a potential consolidation or colocation of regional 911 dispatch services with county and neighboring suburban partners. City Manager Scott Sanders said the city currently budgets "over $6 million a year" for dispatch and that a modeled consolidation could yield long-term savings. He and chiefs cautioned that any merger would require years of careful planning, technology alignment and service-level guarantees: "I do believe we are in a place ... where there is a real opportunity to merge and potentially save," Sanders said, but he stressed that he would not accept a plan that reduced the present level of public-safety performance.
Council and staff also discussed technology and alternative response models — including expanded use of crisis teams, dispatch diversion and new tools such as drones — as possible efficiencies. Several council members stressed the need for public transparency and policy discussions before adopting surveillance or new operational technology.
Next steps: staff will provide more granular, division-level impact statements for police and fire cuts, cost estimates for added officers or fire staffing pilots, and a study plan for dispatch consolidation that addresses technology, staffing and transition timelines.
