Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Land Development topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Commission narrowly rejects Date Street roadway variances aimed at saving tree canopy
Summary
After a lengthy quasi-judicial hearing about drainage, fire access and neighborhood character, the Fernandina Beach City Commission voted 3–2 against requested variances that would have allowed an inverted crown, removed curbs and a modified T turnaround to preserve trees on Date Street.
Kelly Gibson, the city’s director of planning and conservation, told the commission the applicant’s request sought three modifications to local roadway standards for Date Street — an inverted crown to route water to a roadside swale, a modified T turnaround and removal of curb-and-gutter — aimed at preserving tree canopy while allowing a future subdivision to proceed to engineering and TRC review.
"Staff found that all six variance criteria were met," Gibson said, but recommended approval with conditions including that the turnaround adhere to minimum National Fire Protection Association requirements, the use of understory plantings to replace lost canopy, and permeable pavers for driveways to limit impervious area.
Theresa Prince, the applicant’s attorney, said the variance was offered to avoid wholesale removal of trees that would otherwise be required under the city’s standard curb-and-gutter roadway design. "If the variance is denied, the road will be built to absolute standards and the trees will go," Prince said, adding that the modified turnaround would require a deeded dedication of the portion used for the turn to the city.
Asa Gillette, the project engineer, described the inverted crown and a planned dry pond and culvert to collect and convey water from the roadway into an on-site retention area. He said standard turnaround geometries (Y, hammer T, cul-de-sac) would not fit in the existing 60-foot right-of-way without acquiring additional right-of-way from neighbors, so the team proposed a modified T that would use part of Lot 7 and be dedicated to the city.
Residents and affected parties pressed the commission on stormwater risk, pointing to recent extreme storms and the bowl-shaped topography near Citrona that concentrates sheet flow through the Date Street corridor. Pete Stevenson asked the commission to look at broader area drainage, while commissioners asked whether homeowners or a future HOA would maintain proposed private retention features.
Utilities director Andre Desilets and staff said privately maintained stormwater systems typically rely on enforcement by the St. Johns River Water Management District and HOA mechanisms, and that TRC review would still require the developer to demonstrate no off-site adverse impacts.
Commissioner Pointer moved to approve the variance case (20240006) with staff-recommended conditions and findings of fact. After deliberation and a roll-call vote the motion failed by a three-to-two margin. The commission closed the hearing without granting the variances, meaning the applicant can pursue TRC engineering under the standard roadway requirements or return with a revised application.
Next steps: the applicant may revise designs and return to TRC and then to the commission as required by the subdivision and platting process. The commission required that any dedicated right-of-way, turnaround design and pavement structural sections meet city and fire department standards before final approvals.
