Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Meeting Votes topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Historic District Council approves multiple permit actions, allows conditional shed demo
Summary
At its May 15 meeting the Fernandina Beach Historic District Council approved final or conceptual approvals for multiple projects — including an ADU and garage at 30 South 3rd, a new two‑story house with ADU, an accessory building and a Main Street public‑art utility‑box wrap pilot — and cleared demolition of a backyard shed conditioned on salvaging reusable materials.
The Fernandina Beach Historic District Council on May 15 approved a series of routine and contested preservation actions, granting final or conceptual approval for several projects and authorizing the demolition of a non‑historic shed with a salvage condition.
The council voted to approve final plans for the accessory dwelling unit and garage at 30 South 3rd (Case HDC20250002). Staff said the project, which previously received conceptual approval, has begun site work including partial fence construction and pool layout; architect Michael Stauffer confirmed portions of the old garage were salvaged for potential reuse. The board approved the case after a public recusal was recorded and an alternate was seated.
The board also granted final approval to Case HDC20250006, a new two‑story single‑family home with a two‑story ADU on a corner lot at Estrada and Garden Street. Staff flagged changes to the east elevation, a reinforced porch connection and a crushed‑shell path; the applicant, John Dodd, said the revisions addressed previous feedback and the council voted to adopt findings required under the Land Development Code and the historic guidelines.
On a separate application to convert a contributing single‑family residence to commercial use and to add an ADA ramp, the council approved two motions: (1) conditional approval to demolish a mid‑1960s rear shed so long as salvageable materials are salvaged and retained for reuse; and (2) conceptual approval for the remainder of the project (Case HDC20250009), allowing the applicant to proceed with MEP and final design work before returning for final sign‑off.
The board approved Case HDC20250008 (112 S. 10th Street) for a two‑story accessory structure, porch addition, repainting and removal of nonfunctional shutters. Staff recommended final approval and the applicant’s representative, Jose Miranda, described cost‑sensitive simplifications to the design.
Finally, Fernandina Beach Main Street and city partners received conceptual approval to pilot a utility‑box wrapping program that would use historic photographs and Sanborn‑map imagery in a sepia palette at two test locations. Main Street said the project is privately funded; the council asked to be kept informed about agreements with FDOT and the municipal utility (FPU) and requested updates on durability and maintenance plans.
Next steps for the projects approved conceptually include submission of full final plans, MEP engineering for commercial change‑of‑use cases, and staff follow‑up on salvaged material inventories where required. Several items were delegated to future agendas for implementation details and follow‑up reporting.
