Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Public Safety topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Mayor apologizes as city outlines fixes after controversial pool party response
Summary
After a large private pool party in a Birmingham neighborhood drew widespread complaints, Mayor Baller apologized and city officials told residents they are reviewing police, dispatch and code-enforcement coordination; the city attorney also said misdemeanor charges have been filed and arraignments are set for July 22.
Mayor Clinton Baller opened Birmingham’s June 22 meeting with an apology for the police department’s response to a large private pool party that disrupted a residential neighborhood the prior weekend. “We know that we did not perform up to the expectations that you all have,” he said, acknowledging residents’ anger and promising administrative follow-up.
City Manager Jana Ecker described a series of immediate steps the city has taken after a multi‑agency debrief with police, code enforcement and the prosecutor. Ecker said staff have reviewed applicable nuisance and zoning ordinances, discussed improved live coordination between officers and code enforcement, and plan to provide training for dispatchers and officers so that atypical gatherings — including events that appear commercial, involve ticketing, or present public-safety risks — are handled more promptly.
“We had an extensive debriefing process,” Ecker said. She listed possible future actions: earlier use of nuisance and disorderly-gathering charges when an event is trending toward a public-safety incident; directing officers to consult the chief, city attorney or city manager in real time when in doubt; and ensuring police presence during a shutdown to enable an orderly exodus of attendees.
City Attorney Mary Kucharek cautioned residents that several criminal misdemeanor tickets issued after the event will follow the 48th District Court process. “They are not citations,” she said, describing charges for the homeowner (including four counts, one zoning violation and misdemeanor offenses) and the party organizer (noise, disorderly gathering, public nuisance). Kucharek said arraignments are scheduled for July 22.
Residents at the meeting urged faster, clearer, and more consistent enforcement. “I don’t care about that Facebook apology,” said one speaker. “The apology next time is the police doing their job and shutting it down.” Other public speakers said dispatchers had hung up on repeated callers and asked why parked vehicles blocking driveways were not ticketed or towed during the event.
Ecker said the administration will use a resident letter provided in the meeting packet as a template for city responses, will pursue changes to protocols and training, and will investigate options to give neighborhood safety priority when a situation escalates. The commission did not take formal action on these items at the meeting; officials said they will return to the subject with more detail after ongoing reviews and legal constraints are considered.
What’s next: The arraignment in the 48th District Court for those charged is set for July 22; the city manager said she will report back to the commission on protocol and dispatch changes once the internal review and meetings with the prosecutor and police department are complete.
