Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Personnel Medical Testing topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Council approves temporary Hansen Family testing agreement after debate over objective medical screening
Summary
The council narrowly approved a temporary agreement with the Hansen Family organization to provide pre-employment physicals and range-of-motion testing while staff continues to seek objective CRT testing; one councilmember voted against the resolution citing preference for standardized testing and liability concerns.
The Eldora City Council approved a temporary personnel-testing agreement with the Hansen Family organization, drawing discussion about test objectivity and liability before passing the resolution.
The resolution (4253538) covers a temporary arrangement to provide physicals, drug screening and subjective lift/range-of-motion testing for prospective city employees while staff continues researching providers that offer standardized computerized CRT testing. Councilmembers acknowledged a preference for objective, mechanically measured testing but said the city needs a near-term option because previous arrangements were disrupted.
During debate Carrie and other members supported a temporary approval, while one councilmember, Miley, voted no. Don explained his yes vote by saying the agreement provides a baseline for shoulder and knee testing and that he favored limiting liability, while others said they would continue to search for non-subjective providers and pursue grant opportunities with the Hansen Family foundation to acquire objective equipment.
Council approved resolution 4253538 (roll call: Carrie yes; Mike yes; Miley no; Don yes). Staff said that Scott Krueger would administer the testing under the temporary arrangement and that the tests provide a defensible baseline though they can introduce subjectivity.
Next steps: staff will continue to seek objective CRT providers and pursue grant opportunities to acquire standardized testing equipment to reduce subjectivity and medical-liability risk.
