Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Conversion Variance topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Planning board denies request to convert accessory shed into standalone primary structure
Summary
A request to reclassify an accessory shed as a primary structure (creating a separate parcel) was denied after staff and board members cited alley-only access, lack of street frontage and utility limitations; the board found the conversion would create an orphan parcel inconsistent with subdivision and frontage rules.
The Sheldon City Planning & Zoning Board denied a request to convert an accessory shed into a primary structure after board members and staff raised concerns about street frontage, utilities and the creation of a standalone parcel with alley-only access.
The applicant, who said he bought two adjoining properties in 2004 and later remodeled the building, argued the structure had been grandfathered as a nonconforming building and that he had been advised by a prior staff member (which staff could not verify in current records). He described remodeling the roof and raising ceiling height after safety concerns and said the building had its own utility services and had historically been treated as a separate parcel.
Staff and members disagreed that an informal verbal staff comment established legal grandfathering: "we could not verify one way or the other... there's no documentation," staff said. Board members also noted the relevant code requires residential properties to have frontage on a public street and that the lot in question has alley-only access, which complicates utility connections and subdivision compliance.
After discussion the board moved to deny the conversion request on the basis that approving it would create a nonconforming standalone lot without street frontage and with practical limitations for utilities and emergency identification. The motion carried on roll call. The applicant was advised the situation may involve title/abstract issues best addressed with legal counsel and that combining parcels or providing street frontage would be necessary for a compliant primary dwelling conversion.
