Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Library Access And Book Challenges topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Parents press board on Overdrive consortium access and whether Parkland can remove objectionable titles
Summary
Multiple parents at the July 16 meeting urged the Parkland School District to explain the Carbon‑Lehigh IU Overdrive consortium, questioned whether specific titles such as All Boys Aren't Blue would be available to Parkland families, and asked whether the district can block or remove titles retained by the consortium. The board approved renewal of the Overdrive agreement and described an existing challenge process.
At the start of public comment on agenda items, Laura Wormcastle addressed agenda item 8.03 (approval of the Carbon‑Lehigh Intermediate Unit #21 Overdrive consortium agreement) and said she and other parents had asked district staff about the consortium but received limited information. Wormcastle named a specific title, All Boys Aren't Blue, and said the book includes sexual content that she finds inappropriate for children; she said parents were concerned that consortium holdings could be shared with Parkland students and asked whether Parkland could remove a title locally if the consortium retains it.
Wormcastle said she was not calling for a ban but wanted more transparency and local control: “We are buying into a system that we don't even know how we're managing,” she told the board. She asked which districts share material through the consortium and pressed whether Parkland families would be able to prevent specific titles from appearing for local students.
Later in the non‑agenda public comment period, Michael Bodner and David Horvath expanded on similar concerns: Bodner framed the issue as one of age‑appropriateness and parental norms; Horvath said some materials are “sick and disgusting” and urged a clearer, searchable listing of holdings so parents can see what is available.
In response during the administration and board reports, administrators explained that Parkland participates in an IU‑managed Overdrive consortium used by many districts in the region to pool digital resources and lower costs and that professional staff and experts help vet materials on behalf of participating districts. The administration described a defined process for challenges and appeals: community members may bring concerns to administrators, who will follow the established challenge procedure. The administration also noted the board had approved the Overdrive consortium renewal for a one‑year term (July 1, 2024–June 30, 2025) at an annual fee the administration stated as $2,275.
The board approved the Overdrive consortium agreement despite the public comments; administrators said they are willing to meet with concerned parents and review specific titles through the district’s challenge procedure.
