Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Transportation Infrastructure topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
MPO approves TIP amendment after debate over multimillion-dollar cost increases
Summary
The Pioneer Valley MPO endorsed an amendment to the FFY 2025 Transportation Improvement Program that raises budgets on three projects — West Springfield/Chicopee, Agawam Route 57, and Hadley Bay Road bridge — after members questioned whether the increases had been sufficiently vetted.
The Pioneer Valley Metropolitan Planning Organization voted to approve Amendment 1 to the federal fiscal year 2025 Transportation Improvement Program, a change staff said is needed to reflect revised project descriptions, updated funding sources and substantial cost increases on three projects.
Staff described the three cost increases as: the West Springfield/Chicopee pavement and bridge preservation project rising from about $5.76 million to just over $9 million; the Agawam rotary and Route 57 resurfacing increasing from roughly $8.625 million to about $13.315 million; and the Hadley Bay Road bridge project moving from $5.7 million to $7.2 million. Andrew McCaul (PVPC) told members MassDOT supplied a clarifying comment on how a portion of the West Springfield increase will be split among funding sources.
Not all members were satisfied with that explanation. Member Mark Gold said he remained troubled by the magnitude of some increases and the apparent absence of the same vetting applied to the original projects. "I mean, from 5.7 to 9.3 million. That's not an increase. That's just a redo of the project," Gold said, arguing for closer initial scoping by project sponsors.
Walter Gunn disagreed in part, noting a recent change in state roadwork regulations had driven cost increases in some projects. "Don't forget we did have some changes to state regulations on road work done last spring," he said, adding that specification changes can raise project costs even when bids are competitive.
After discussion, Walter Gunn moved to approve the amendment and Doug Slaughter seconded. The roll-call vote recorded five yes votes and two no votes: David Mohler (MassDOT), Mark Moore, Walter Gunn, Douglas Slaughter and Northampton Mayor Gina-Louise Sciarra voted yes; Joshua A. Garcia and Mark Gold voted no. The amendment passed and staff said the changes allow the projects to advance into their next design and procurement steps.
The MPO recorded that the cost increases include both newly identified work (additional bridge repairs and related items) and delays that raised inflation-driven costs (the Hadley project was pushed out of a previous year, staff said). The MPO directed staff to incorporate MassDOT's clarifying comment on funding allocation into the final amendment documentation.
The MPO's action updates project budgets in the TIP but does not, by itself, change local permitting or right-of-way responsibilities; those continue to be handled by municipal sponsors and MassDOT as applicable.
