Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Public Art topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
St. Helena council approves temporary public-art loan agreement, contingent on Parks & Recreation review
Summary
The council authorized a loan agreement to install 13 temporary public-art pieces by artist Gordon Huether downtown and on private parcels, approving the contract tonight subject to review by the Parks & Recreation Commission on March 16; the decision followed public concern about timing and process.
The Saint Helena City Council voted to approve a loan agreement to bring 13 temporary public-art pieces to the city, but conditioned final installation on expedited review by the Parks and Recreation Commission.
City Manager Camillo introduced the item, saying the proposal "is about authorizing the staff to enter into contracts" to accept art loaned by artist Gordon Huether and that the installations are temporary, "until 2027." Director of Community Services Ashley Sylvester told the council the pieces would be installed by city staff in coordination with the artist; the city will absorb material and staff costs for concrete pads while the artist will cover transportation and most installation expenses. Sylvester summarized the program goals as a quick way to increase public art and to help stand up a more formal public-arts program for the city.
Council members asked for clearer cost estimates. Camillo and Sylvester gave a range of figures during the discussion: staff cited approximately $6,000 in equipment and vendor rentals for installation and noted staff-time costs. At one point staff referenced a larger staff-time estimate, then clarified the installation-equivalent staff-time cost as about $8,000; Camillo also said the city’s insurance pool (CIRA) estimated coverage under $1,500 annually. Sylvester said the artist cannot remove pieces before March 2027 and the city would receive a 20% fee on any pieces sold before removal.
A member of the public raised a Brown Act concern about a revised contract being posted only hours before the meeting, asking the council to delay the item so residents could meaningfully review the changes. The speaker said, "Releasing a revised agreement only hours before the meeting makes it impossible for residents to determine whether the terms being approved tonight are the same terms that have previously been discussed." City Attorney Walsh responded that the city clerk reposted the amended item to the agenda simultaneously with sending it to council and that the Brown Act permits in-meeting changes so long as the public had notice of the matter.
Vice Mayor Deasy and other council members urged adherence to the city’s public-art policy and recommended Parks and Recreation vetting; staff said the city sought to expedite the installations for the city’s 150th anniversary but recognized the need for public input. Mayor Paul Jamieson Dohring moved to approve the loan agreement "subject to review and approval of the public art project by the Parks and Recreation Commission," a motion seconded and approved on a roll-call vote. The vote recorded yes from Council member Barrick, Council member Spataroto, Vice Mayor Dizzi and Mayor Dohring (4–0).
The council directed staff to place the project on the Parks and Recreation Commission agenda for March 16 for review prior to installation. Staff said installation had been scheduled to begin the week following that meeting, contingent on Parks and Recreation review.
