Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Abortion Policy topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Tennessee House approves civil cause of action aimed at out‑of‑state abortion‑pill providers
Summary
On final passage the House approved Senate Bill 419, which creates a wrongful‑death civil cause of action for families of unborn children allegedly killed when out‑of‑state providers send abortion pills into Tennessee. Sponsors said the measure is intended to deter illegal distribution; opponents raised constitutional and interstate‑commerce concerns.
The Tennessee House approved Senate Bill 419 on third and final reading after floor debate and recorded roll‑call votes.
Sponsor remarks during debate described the measure as creating “a cause of action in favor of the family of any unborn child who is killed by an out of state abortionist illegally sending abortion pills into the state of Tennessee,” a change supporters said is intended to deter cross‑border distribution of medication. "This bill creates a cause of action in favor of the family of any unborn child who is killed by an out‑of‑state abortionist illegally sending abortion pills into the state of Tennessee," the sponsor said on the floor.
Opponents urged further review. Representative Behn argued the bill conflicted with the federal interstate commerce clause and moved to recommit the measure to the Judiciary Committee for additional consideration; that motion failed on a recorded vote. In floor exchanges members asked whether federal court jurisdiction and so‑called "shield" statutes in other states could blunt enforcement; proponents said civil suits could be brought in federal court under diversity jurisdiction where appropriate.
The House recorded a roll‑call result on final passage that the Clerk reported as 71 yeas, 23 nays and 1 present, not voting. The bill sponsor and multiple backers characterized the package as part of a longstanding effort by the state to limit out‑of‑state actors from undermining Tennessee's statutes regulating abortion‑related medications.
Next steps: With House passage complete, the bill returns to the enrolling process and then to the Senate (or to the governor, per chamber procedure) for the next steps toward enactment.
