Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the School Technology topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Commissioners approve five‑year lease for 5,450 iPads for Alamance Burlington schools after divided debate
Summary
The board approved a five‑year lease purchase with Apple Financial Services for 5,450 student iPads, committing to annual payments of approximately $423,907; the measure passed 4–1 after commissioners raised procurement, pedagogy and cost concerns.
The Alamance County Board of Commissioners approved a five‑year lease‑purchase agreement on April 6 to fund 5,450 student iPads and supporting equipment for the Alamance‑Burlington School System (ABSS), with an annual county obligation of $423,906.82.
Dennis Fry, ABSS chief technology officer, told the board the district requests authorization because the five‑year arrangement is a multiyear financial commitment that requires county approval. He said the lease is a 0% financing vehicle tied to a consortium contract and that the agreement will allow the district to replace aging student devices on a steady schedule rather than a one‑time large purchase.
"This will replace equipment ... right now, that is about 6½ years old," Fry said, and added the district plans K–5 deployments and teacher training in pilot schools. Fry said the district expects iPads to retain value better than Chromebooks and that Apple pricing has become more competitive.
Several commissioners pressed ABSS on the decision to move from Chromebooks (the statewide dominant platform) to iPads for elementary grades. Commissioner (S6) argued the shift conflicts with state standardization trends and cited research he said shows tablet reading can be detrimental for low‑skill early readers; he asked for a formal price‑analysis and legal opinion on sole‑source procurement exemptions.
Fry responded that the devices are procured through a state/consortium contract and that the district intends to keep Chromebooks in secondary grades while using iPads in elementary classrooms where touchscreen applications can support targeted instruction. He also said the district intends the devices to stay at school and receive training and curriculum support.
After debate and a failed motion to postpone, the board took a substitute motion to approve the lease and associated resolution. The motion carried by voice vote, recorded as 4–1.
What the approval means
The county is authorizing a multiyear capital commitment to support ABSS's lease payments; ABSS officials said the requested annual payment is already anticipated within the capital budget planning for school technology. Commissioners asked staff to prepare a legal opinion on competitive‑bidding and sole‑source issues ahead of April 20 follow‑up materials; ABSS agreed to provide supporting research and pricing details.
