Warner Select Board votes not to recommend 4% tax-cap citizen petition after hearing

The Warner Select Board on Feb. 17 heard public comment on a citizen petition to adopt RSA 32:5-b and limit year-over-year increases in the amount raised by local property taxes to 4%, then voted 2-1 not to recommend the measure to voters.

During the public hearing, resident Bob LaFrance asked whether the proposed 4% cap would apply annually. Select Board member Mike Smith replied that he reads the petition as preventing a budget that increases the amount to be raised by local taxes by more than 4% from the prior fiscal year. Resident James Sherman presented data saying Warner’s own portion of the tax rate rose far less than the school portion in recent years, stating that "from 2015 through 2025 the overall expenses in Warner increased annually 1.89% and capital increased 3%" and that the school portion of the tax rate increased about 76% over that period while the town’s portion rose about 23%.

Seidel and Hanson said they shared concerns about unintended impacts on town services if a strict cap were adopted. After discussion, the Board recorded a recommendation of “Not recommend” by roll call: Alfred Hanson — not recommend; Harry Seidel — not recommend; Mike Smith — recommend. The Select Board formally closed the public hearing at 6:24 PM.

Why it matters: Supporters of the petition said a cap would restrain future tax increases; opponents and some board members said the town’s limited control over school and state-driven components of the tax rate could leave municipal services vulnerable if revenue were constrained. The issue will appear on the annual warrant for town meeting consideration.

What’s next: The Select Board’s recommendation will be included with the warrant materials for the March 2026 town meeting vote.