Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Land Use Rezoning topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Germantown trustees reject rezoning and conditional-use permit for Meeker Hill tree-removal site
Summary
The Germantown Village Board declined a rezoning and conditional-use permit for a proposed tree-removal and firewood business at Meeker Hill Lane after staff outlined a history of code violations and residents submitted opposition; the planning commission had recommended denial.
Germantown — The Village Board on July 6 declined to approve a rezoning and conditional-use permit that would have allowed a tree-removal and firewood-processing business to operate on 2.1 acres at W212 N11206 Meeker Hill Lane.
Staff planner Jeff told the board the application, brought by agent Brandon O'Brien for property owner Randall Wendland, would have allowed a 50-by-120-foot building, on-site equipment storage and servicing, and 10 to 15 employees working roughly 7:30 a.m. until dusk. Jeff told trustees that village records show a prior tree-service operation on the lot going back to 2002 but that the earlier business was "never deemed to be a legal use of the property" and had accrued multiple code violations, which in staff’s view "does not justify the rezoning requests today." (Jeff)
The planning commission reviewed the application in June and recommended denial. Jeff said the village received 15 emailed comments opposing the requests and one resident appeared in person at the planning hearing in opposition. Trustees debated the land-use consistency with Germantown’s 2050 comprehensive plan, which designates the Meeker Hill area for low-density residential use and discourages new business zoning in the neighborhood.
A motion to approve the rezoning and conditional-use permit was called and discussed; after the board vote the motion did not pass. The transcript records voices on both sides of the vote and later statements that the motion failed; a precise roll-call tally was not provided in the meeting record.
Resident Melanie Smythe, who spoke during citizen input earlier in the meeting, told the board she had raised several concerns with staff and project representatives about the police department building contract and the makeup of the project team, and urged a financial forensic audit to help the new village administrator and finance director. Smythe also noted earlier capital-plan estimates for the police facility and said recent cost changes merited further review. (Melanie Smythe)
The board did not adopt the rezoning or the conditional-use permit; no alternative approval or amendment to the request was recorded. The meeting adjourned at about 7:20 p.m.
