Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Municipal Leasing topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Debate over Birdie’s lease amendment highlights revenue and maintenance tradeoffs; council approves amendment
Summary
Council approved an amendment to Birdie’s Restaurant lease shifting building maintenance to the tenant and updating financial terms after council members pressed administration on 10‑year revenue projections and estimated maintenance costs.
The Dearborn City Council approved a lease amendment July 14 that shifts maintenance responsibilities for the Birdie’s Restaurant building and updates financial terms after extended discussion over revenue forecasts and long‑term maintenance costs.
Deputy Parks and Recreation Director Jonathan Golis told the council the administration kept revenue estimates flat when calculating a 10‑year projection. Council member Abraham said that approach understates likely revenues and that the city could lose up to about $1 million over ten years compared with alternate projections. ‘‘I think the city is giving up a lot on the stream of revenue from leasing almost the entire facility,’’ Abraham said during the debate.
Carl Mackey, the owner‑operator of Birdie’s, described his investment and operational challenges: ‘‘We employ over 50 people in the city. We cleaned up the golf course significantly ... we spent ... we had $19,000 in sales for the pro shop, and we’re at a $21,000 cost,’’ he said, explaining that low current demand and ongoing renovation and parking issues make a predictable lease important to the business.
Council members discussed net present value and the tradeoff between avoiding a large, upfront city outlay for maintenance and accepting somewhat lower projected lease revenue. Some members said they wished they had more time to analyze the numbers; others said the long‑term goal was to stabilize an otherwise struggling course and property.
The amendment clarifies tenant responsibility for exterior maintenance, requires an annual roof inspection, establishes a base monthly rent of $8,000 and a 3% annual rent increase starting in a later year; it included immediate effect and received unanimous assent in the meeting’s roll call.
What happens next: The city will implement the lease amendment, monitor operational outcomes at Birdie’s and track the intended improvements to the golf course, including ongoing sprinkler and nine‑hole restoration work.
