Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Construction Contracts topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Board approves Cascade Falls pay application after lengthy debate; requires 5-year warranty and suspend 14 days of liquidated damages
Summary
After prolonged debate over alleged defects at the Cascade Falls overlook, the Osceola Village Board approved Pembroke Companies’ pay application conditionally — requiring a five-year warranty and suspending 14 days of liquidated damages — in a 5–1 vote.
Drew, an MSA engineer, told the Osceola Village Board that Pembroke Companies had submitted a revised Pay Application No. 4 for the Cascade Falls project and that MSA had increased retainage to 5 percent and was withholding an additional $130,000 while outstanding punch-list items were resolved. “I believe that per the contract and per spec that we have received all of the work that we’ve ordered,” Drew said during the presentation, adding the contractor provided written notice of completion and that MSA planned a final walk-through before final reconciliation.
Board member Mike pushed back, enumerating what he described as construction deficiencies: misaligned railings, loose diagonal bracing, epoxy on pier tops and other deviations from the delegated design. “I’m going to vote no on all of this,” Mike said, describing the work as “not built right” and urging a third-party review.
Other trustees joined that concern and raised the prospect of hiring an independent engineering firm to review plans, submittals and the as-built condition. Board members discussed options including removing disputed items from the pay request, increasing retainage, or approving payment while holding funds to underwrite a third-party inspection. Drew said the structural engineer who reviewed the delegated design reported anchor and clearance requirements were met and reminded the board a one-year warranty covers the work as-built.
After extended questioning about anchor bolts, decking deflection and welding quality, the board made a compromise motion: approve the pay application conditioned on Pembroke executing a change order that extends the warranty to five years and suspends liquidated damages from June 15–29 as proposed by MSA. The measure passed 5–1.
What happens next: MSA will coordinate a final walk-through with the contractor and owner; the board directed staff to pursue a change order documenting the five-year warranty and to consider third-party review if additional deficiencies surface. Several trustees said the retained funds should be sufficient to pay for limited verification but warned further deficiencies could require more extensive remediation or legal options.
Votes and numbers: the board noted roughly $265,000 of retainage would remain after the payment; the project’s overall expenditures cited in discussion approached $1.4 million, of which roughly $700,000 was described as taxpayer-funded in the meeting comments. The board’s conditional approval is intended to release a portion of the requested payment while preserving remedies for the village.
