Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Designation 1242 Dover Lane topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Commission designates 1242 Dover Lane as a structure of merit amid divided views on its significance
Summary
The Historic Landmarks Commission voted to designate the 1927 Leonard Cook house at 1242 Dover Lane as a structure of merit after debate over whether its simple Spanish Colonial Revival expression and association with architect Leonard Cook meet the commission's criteria.
The Historic Landmarks Commission voted on July 15 to designate 1242 Dover Lane, a 1927 Spanish Colonial Revival house associated with architect Leonard Austin Cook, as a structure of merit.
Staff and the architectural historian summarized the house's history and character-defining features, including smooth whitewashed stucco, clay tile roof, wood-divided-sash windows recessed into stucco walls, an arched entry with heavy wood door, and an original sandstone retaining wall. The nomination drew on past historic significance reports and phase-1/phase-2 assessments prepared in 2021'22.
Commission discussion split on the property's merits. Some commissioners argued the house is a simple but high-integrity example of Spanish Colonial Revival and that Cook's regional work supports designation under criterion C. Others said large windows and roof pitch make it a weak exemplar and questioned whether Cook qualifies as a "master" in this context. After debate, the commission approved the designation by roll call (motion passed; recorded votes included one 'no' and one abstention). The resolution will be signed as customary.
The commission noted that while the house is modest on the stylistic scale, it retains a high level of historic integrity from the public way and conveys its 1927 appearance. The designation will be recorded and the applicant/staff will complete the resolution formalities.
