Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Historic Preservation topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Historic Landmarks Commission designates 1242 Dover Lane a structure of merit amid mixed views
Summary
The Historic Landmarks Commission voted to designate 1242 Dover Lane, a 1927 Spanish Colonial Revival house by Leonard A. Cook, as a structure of merit after staff presentation and debate about stylistic integrity; the motion passed with two denials and one abstention.
The Historic Landmarks Commission voted to designate 1242 Dover Lane as a structure of merit, citing the property's 1927 Spanish Colonial Revival character, its architect Leonard Austin Cook and its retention of original massing and materials.
An architectural historian summarized the property's history and features, noting its cross-gabled clay tile roof, smooth whitewashed stucco, recessed wood‑divided sash windows and original sandstone retaining wall. The presentation referenced earlier surveys and phase reports (2021–2022) that documented the house’s integrity.
Commission debate centered on how exemplary the building is as Spanish Colonial Revival architecture. Commissioner Lundbeck argued the house is “simply a white plaster building” and questioned whether it rises to the level of a structure of merit. Other commissioners, including Vice Chair Ullie and Commissioner Hansberry, defended its simplicity, retention of original massing and overall integrity, and said that simplicity can still be historically significant.
The roll‑call vote recorded several yes votes with two denials and one abstention; with a majority in favor the designation passed and the commission arranged for the resolution to be signed.
What happens next: The resolution process will be completed and the property’s new designation will be recorded on the local register of historic resources.
