Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Oysters topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Commission adopts compromise oyster plan: limited deep‑water recovery areas, cultch rotation and adaptive management
Summary
The Marine Fisheries Commission approved a package in Amendment 5 for eastern oysters that designates reduced deep‑water oyster recovery areas, adopts a culture‑supported harvest approach and a rotational cultch‑site strategy, and directs adaptive management and further work on recreational data and restoration.
Division biologists presented Amendment 5 for the Eastern Oyster Fishery Management Plan and recommended a three‑part approach: designate deep‑water oyster recovery areas (DORAs) to protect vulnerable deep reefs, shift mechanical‑harvest management to a culture‑supported model with clearer preseason and in‑season sampling and season lengths, and establish rotational cultch planting sites that could be opened in a managed rotation to provide harvest opportunities while allowing recovery elsewhere.
Bennett Paradis and Joe Fashendela of the division explained that deepwater reefs have lost most vertical relief and that mechanical dredging can remove as much as a foot of reef height per pass; they said recovery requires vertical relief to escape low‑oxygen events and that protected areas would allow reefs to rebuild shell height over years. "The nonfished reef will gain height over time," one biologist summarized, noting monitoring through side‑scan and diver surveys.
The commission considered advisory committee input and public comment. Regional committees were split: some supported the division's intermediate‑size DORA, others preferred status quo or a narrower box. Public commenters—commercial harvesters, processors, and county officials—urged careful consideration of economic impacts, more accurate surveys for species such as blue crab, and active restoration (cultch planting or relay) to accelerate recovery.
After debate and amendments the commission substituted and adopted the division's recommended (middle‑size) DORA option, and approved the culture‑supported harvest strategy, a rotational cultch‑site program, and adaptive management provisions. Commissioners emphasized the need for follow‑up work to pair area protection with active cultch planting and cross‑agency efforts on water quality.
Division staff will monitor metrics including reef height and complexity, provide year‑0 and ongoing monitoring data, and report back in the next FMP cycle. The commission directed staff to explore options to better estimate recreational shellfish participation and data collection mechanisms to support long‑term stock assessments.
