Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Energy Procurement topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Board raises questions about energy consortium contract terms and potential hidden costs
Summary
Board members debated joining a large energy purchasing consortium, expressing support for purchasing power but concern about 'lock‑in' clauses, lack of caps on delivery fees and the difference between quoted kilowatt‑hour rates and total billed costs.
At its regular meeting the Ravena‑Coeymans‑Selkirk Central School District Board of Education debated whether to approve participation in a much larger energy consortium that would set maximum contract rates but could lock the district into multi‑year terms.
Board members split along practical lines: some said the purchasing power and administrative simplicity of a large consortium would improve budgeting and reduce volatility; others warned the district could be ‘locked in’ to higher costs if ancillary charges such as delivery fees and other components were not bounded by the contract. One board member noted the current quoted electric rate as “0.0934” per kilowatt hour but cautioned that the posted figure is the maximum and that total billed costs (including delivery and other charges) can be materially higher.
Another board member explained the practical confusion around price presentation: “When you look at the electricity bill… they say the cost per kilowatt hour is 9¢… You have to factor in… delivery charges… it’s probably 18¢ or 20¢,” and urged the board to consider total cost rather than a single line item. Several members asked staff to provide historical charges and comparisons with what other consortium members paid so the board can see last year’s actual bills versus the contract’s maximums.
Despite the concerns, the board approved the block of business that included setting contract limits by voice vote; members asked staff to follow up with more detailed rate comparisons and to return with a report next year if needed.
Provenance: topicintro SEG 261; topfinish SEG 454.
