Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Utilities Metering topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Panama City staff warn of cascading meter failures, seek $2.4M push and upgrades to keep water billing accurate
Summary
City public‑works staff told the Panama City Commission they have driven water loss from about 30% to just over 8% but face continuing meter and MXU failures that are causing estimated billing and revenue loss; staff proposed a ~$2.4–$2.5 million expedited purchase to replace ~6,000 meters and accelerate repairs, and also outlined staffing, fleet and lift‑station needs.
Clint Murphy, the city’s director of public works, told the commission at the July 16 pre‑budget workshop that utility crews have reduced system water loss “from about 30% last year to just over 8% this year,” crediting recent infrastructure projects and targeted replacements. He warned, however, that thousands of residential meters and MXUs are failing and causing frequent estimated bills for residents.
“Part of the problem is supply,” Murphy said. He described a scenario in which a $2.4–$2.5 million one‑time purchase of meters and transmitters would allow contractors to install roughly 500 meters a week and bring the system back into balance within about 11 weeks, replacing approximately 6,000 units and substantially reducing future waves of simultaneous failure.
Commissioners pressed staff for detail on alternatives and costs. Staff said an expedited replacement would reduce the chance of another large concentrated failure a decade from now and that the FY27 budget already increases the amount budgeted for meters; they also discussed a lower‑cost meter option that allows in‑place battery replacement rather than a full pull and reinstall.
Murphy also reviewed other enterprise fund items that affect service levels: public‑works crews collect about 15,000 tons of garbage a year for roughly 13,600 customers, the litter crew expanded from two to four workers in FY26, and the fleet shop maintains roughly 875 vehicles and manages more than 5,100 work orders annually. He reported losing three experienced mechanics recently and requested $135,000 in capital for a lube system and other shop improvements to improve safety and throughput.
On lift stations and wastewater, Murphy reminded the commission the city operates about 140 lift stations and is pursuing multiple grant efforts to harden and modernize critical sites. He said designs for 11 lift‑station hardening projects funded under FEMA’s Hazard Mitigation Grant Program are complete and awaiting final regional approval.
Why it matters: failing meters mean estimated bills and frustrated residents; a one‑time investment to replace a large share of meters could produce quicker, more accurate billing and reduce lost revenue, but would require scarce capital. The commission asked staff for procurement details, a clearer plan to avoid future synchronized replacements, and comparisons of meter technologies and lifecycle costs.
What’s next: staff said they will return with cost comparisons between meter products, procurement timing, and a purchase schedule, and highlighted that some funding could come from the city’s infrastructure surtax if the commission directs it.
