Local dentists urge reversing water fluoridation removal; commissioners weigh referendum as state bill looms

Dr. Wendy Treasure, a local dentist, used the public‑comment period at the March 11 meeting to urge the City Commission to reconsider the Utility Commission’s recent decision to remove fluoride from New Smyrna Beach’s water supply.

Dr. Treasure said community water fluoridation is “a safe, effective and research‑backed public health measure” that reduces tooth decay, particularly among children and underserved communities, and asked the commission not to dismantle remaining equipment and to place the issue before voters or otherwise reinstate fluoridation.

Several commissioners acknowledged the public comment and discussed next steps. Commissioner McGurk said she had met with local dental professionals and considered asking the commission for a resolution supporting fluoridation, but flagged pending state legislation (Senate Bill 700) that could remove local control. Commissioners discussed the mechanics and cost of a referendum and whether legislative action might make a local referendum futile.

Why it matters: The issue affects public‑health policy, utility operations and potential utility‑rate or capital costs should equipment need to be reinstalled. Public comments asked the commission to preserve equipment to keep future reversals feasible.

What was decided: No immediate policy change or referendum was adopted at the meeting. Commissioners directed staff and the city attorney to watch state action and report back; any decision to pursue a referendum would require ordinance language, cost estimates, and clarity about state preemption.

Representative quote: Dr. Wendy Treasure said, “Fluoridated water is a safe effective and research back public health measure and for decades it’s been proven to reduce tooth decay and improve oral health, particularly for children and underserved communities.”